Who would have thought it normal for a 22 year old to give online dating a serious shot?
You’re absolutely right….no one.
Outgoing and confident enough to strike up a conversation anywhere, I have always tried just that: if you are a man over 6’0 and have a nice smile, I probably have hit on you (and I’m not sorry). You name it, I’ve tried it…grocery stores, libraries, lectures, bars, restaurants, ferries, busses, movies (I apologize, I didn’t realize you were on a date), the gym (bad idea), coffee shops, malls, planes…I’ve hit on everyone, everywhere, in search of my perfect mate. I remember walking up to a crush in 8th grade and asking if he’d be my boyfriend…he wasn’t feeling that. During the summer of my third year of university, I went on over 40 first dates…and there was rarely a second.
I’ve dated you all: tall, short, jocks, nerds, nice guys, romantics, poets, professionals, students, divorcees, old, young. We date, we check things off our ‘make sure he has this’ list, and evaluate our compatibility. Call me quick to judge or maybe a picky bitch, but alas, at 22, I have struck out more than A-Rod during post-season.
So, shit out of luck and failing haaaaard meeting suitable suitors, and often shooting dirty looks to the sparkly-eyed strangers walking down the street hand in hand, I resorted to my favourite thing: math. I would dissect it, make it an equation, and solve it.

It is so damn simple – billions of people, I’m technically keeping it small scale, regardless of the fact I would hit on anyone. I’m still only approaching people at a particular place at a particular time. To succeed, I’d have to broaden my audience, my network, increase probability of meeting someone I am truly compatible with, almost entirely removing the negative factor of time/place. What about cupid? Well, he can still strike when I physically meet the person. There still has to be that chemistry, that spark, that moment where you blush and realize that you’re in the presence of a pretty great catch.
It’s like job hunting – your resume might be great, but if you don’t hit it off with your potential employer, they’ll say nice meeting you and take care. There is still the need for our lovely little friend with wings and bows and arrows. Why do you think I always dress as cupid for Halloween? I believe in it. I still hope for it.
How? Duh.
Staring (appalled) at these married couples on television, claiming to have met online, my own curiousity forced me to contemplate the idea of internet dating for a very, very long time. It’s been a year that I’ve been toying with the idea, secretively, not wanting to share my ‘ridiculous’ new idea for adventure with any of my friends for fear of harassment, no matter how unmoving.
Temptation. Shit. Don’t tempt me with the cookie because I’ll bite your hand off, along with the sweet, melting ball of gooey goodness.
Concerns in tow, I signed up on two sites for testing: plentyoffish.com, and eharmony.ca. The former is free and the latter charges a monthly fee (about $40).
One of my guy friends recommended Plentyoffish.com to me. He’s on it, and has had varied success (and by varied, I mean non-existent…he’s still single). Up for anything, I gave it a try. This particular site played host to a younger generation of online daters, leading me to believe that free site = craigslist.org feel…as in anyone, anywhere, pretending to be anyone doing anything, and with the potential to be totally fucking creepy can be however they want to be and talk to whoever they want to talk to. Don’t get me wrong, this could happen on a paying site as well, however I tend to think paying members are slightly less creepy…then again, there are plenty of paying members on plenty of raunchy porn sites, so this theory won’t hold.
I can’t lie about it: after being on plentyoffish.com for less than a day, I deleted my profile. The registration form only requires a few questions be answered, mostly on a superficial level, and people can browse your profile…so, let’s say we’ve got Boy #1 and Boy #2. Boy #1: occupation…who really knows, but he’s about 45 and is testing the online dating. Boy #2: millwright, 27, good looking, jaded, hoping to find some luck online. Let’s say boy #1 is looking for female between ages 18-35 in the Vancouver area, my profile shows up. Boy #2 is looking for female, aged 21-29, who has an interest in music, sports, and adventure…my profile shows up. It winds up being a bummer for each party…girl getting creeped-out by Boy #1, therefore being skeptical of Boy #2. If you are remotely good looking, expect upwards of 20+ hits in…well, less than a day. Again, I can’t lie: I MAYBE would have toyed with the idea of chatting with one, and only one of the people who scoped me out. Worst idea ever.
Neeeeext.
Eharmony.ca prompts the user to fill out a multitude of questionnaires, ranging from the simplest question about what you hope for in a partner to the most in depth reflection of your own habits. After the 400th question, I was starting to feel disgruntled, but I plugged away and completed my profile. My answers to these questions create my ‘personality profile’, and ridiculously long and detailed description of…well, me. After reading it, I realize the thousands of dollars I have spent on a shrink were wasted; staring at the computer, the most psycho-analytical piece of literature ever written about me, and only me, practically mocked me from inside the screen. What’s more interesting is that this is ‘private’, and won’t be shared with your matches unless you approve it to be. Hmph.
Another interesting and fantastic tidbit: On Eharmony.ca, a user cannot browse profiles. I cannot ‘search’ for anyone, and no one can ‘search’ for me. Site administration sends the user potential matches based on the users questionnaire answer. Fantastic!
Creepiness factor has diminished exponentially already.
Reviewing some of my matches, it became clear that the vast majority of profiles were 30+. This tickles my fancy, as I’m one for sitting down to conversation with someone with an abundance of life experience. Is that too old for me? Growing up in the small-town, country lifestyle, my answer is yes, but I’d be up for testing the water. Two major concerns: 1) will the 30+ take me seriously, as a 22 year old professional, and 2) is it creepy that the 30+ thinks it’s okay to date a 22 year old? The latter makes me shudder.
Deep breath. Out of the 30 matches I’ve been sent over the past week, I have only really continued the ‘guided’ communication process with 2 Eharmony.ca boys. So far, so good. “Guided Communication” refers to the ‘taking turns’ approach. Eharmony.ca provides a list of questions that I can ask the users – if they like my profile, they can answer my question and ask their own. Then we send each other our “must haves/can’t stands”…we filled these out during the initial questionnaire. Interesting. We can then ask ‘open’ questions, either typing our own, or selecting a list – answers are basically essay-format. Back in University again, only this time it’s more fun! After a series of question and answer sessions, the users may engage in open communication…email within the Eharmony.ca site. Did you just hear my stomach drop to my ass? In my head, the voice chants: why the hell are they even considering a 22 year old? That number is so low, it makes me look like an infant, in turn making them look like creeps. Fuck.
Self-consciousness exists online, too. Wow.
Before writing these little emails, I re-read their profiles, just to make sure I actually WOULD like/date/be friendly with these boys. Funny, they’re pretty much exactly the same. 27 and 28, engineer and financial advisor, well-traveled, ambitious, want babies, over 6’2, claim to be funny, fit, and fantastic all-around. Great thing about the internet is the ability to lie or be completely truthful…both are tempting! Personally, with the jaded history I like to believe I have, I chose to be completely truthful. It’s so easy to tell a man what I expect in a relationship when I haven’t even met him (not to mention, don’t have to look him in the eye). One of the questions the 27 year old asked is what I expect/want in a relationship partner…I didn’t hesitate to write exactly what I wanted! Honesty…wow. Powerful. He did the same, and it pleased me to see that there were boys who are just as frustrated as us girls. Hurray, I love gaining new perspective!
Communication with the two boys continues…they want to know why a girl who seems so interesting, intelligent, and has a striking photo would be trying online dating. I want to know the same about them. Why is it that we assume because people are engaging in online dating that they can’t get it elsewhere? I definitely still am skeptical, but I also think I’m taking part in a huge movement for our generation. Perhaps I’m just a little early for this age group, but as my girlfriend pointed out, I’m really just increasing my options, not ‘giving up’ at real life encounters. No matter how I look at this, I’ll be able to justify it…maybe not so much if I’m lying naked in bed with someone I met online...wince. In all of this, I’m still at the rookie stage of contemplating the different lies I can come up with as to how I met the person, and convince ‘boy’ that he should too. Maybe I’m an idiot. My paranoia is enough thinking for an entire community so sometimes it’s easiest to just think for myself an take the opinions of others with a grain of salt.
So many factors, and whether it be online or in person, the issue of age differences still intrigue me. Age, like where we meet, should have no matter. I’m always looking for the best match, the ideal guy for me. Someone to relate to, someone to share adventures with. Whether I meet him online or at a hockey game, his smile will catch me, the conversation will sway me, and if he makes me laugh…oh wow, he’s so in.

Online dating acts as a filtration system, basically skipping past the superficial layers of the dating onion. Imagine only ever meeting the boys that suited your superficial interests: mine? Taller than me with big, true smile. Imagine finding out their interests, passions, goals, occupation, pet peeves, all before the first date…pretty much saving yourself the awkwardness and the money. That being said, you’ve also opted to forego the butterfly feelings, the fretting of what to wear. If your online communication really goes anywhere and you do wind up meeting the individual, the butterflies will still be there, but so will the potential for possibly having chosen a loser and/or a fraud.
Pro: it allows the user to decline further communication with an individual, for whatever reason. Con: your ego can still be bruised online. Pro: it’s easier to maintain your own ‘standard’ without the risk of the time/place theory. Con: online is online…face to face is always more valuable when it comes to chemistry and really getting a feel for someone.
So, without putting on make up or pearls, I could have found out that the guy in the grocery doesn’t eat meat, but I wouldn’t find that out until the 4th date. Honey, steak will be bbq’d in my house. The guy in the library was researching how to make bombs. Cool. Too bad you’re beautiful. The guy at the lecture was actually stalking his ex. Guy are the bar was into boys. Man at the restaurant was waiting for his mother to show up – he still lives her. The guy on the ferry was a magician (totally cool) and married. Boy on the bus was incredibly shy and turned into a mute after I complimented his tie. At the movies? On a date. Dude at the gym was just that…a total dude. At the mall, well, he just wasn’t interested. On the plane, the beautiful stranger loudly announced a few negative opinions on a variety of races and religions. And you, in the elevator, well you thought I wasn’t in it for the long-term…when really that’s all I’m looking for. You would have known that if you met me online. But then I would have realized you are someone who is quick to judge, and I wouldn’t have been interested.
Online? Reality without having to take a shower.